| Trust your 'wisdom of repugnance,' noted
ethicist advises Seminary audience PHILADELPHIA -- Christians and others
shouldn't leave the discussion of critical ethical issues to specialists in such fields as
biomedical ethics and technology.
And when they feel repugnance about developments in such matters as the dominance of
consumerism, the prevalence of violence in the media, the loss of civility in society or
the breakdown of the family, they should discuss their concerns both publicly and
privately.
Those were key points made recently by Dr. Jean Bethke Elshtain, the Laura Spelman
Rockefeller Professor of Social and Political Ethics at the University of Chicago. She
spoke at The Lutheran Theological Seminary at Philadelphia on "The Ethical Challenges
of the New Century: How Do Christians Respond?" Her appearance was made possible as
part of the annual Hein-Fry Lecture Series.
Frequently referring to the writings and thought of 20th Century religious
figures Dietrich Bonhoeffer and Pope John Paul II, Elshtain voiced criticism over the
modern practice of "slothfulness." She defined slothfulness, a sin not often
discussed today, as a tendency "toward acquiescence, a refusal to be
self-critical" over such trends as the predominance of economic forces in defining
societal values. Such indolence leads to a destructive loss of self and a "denial of
the complex joys" that embody the human identity, she said.
She described human freedom as always being in relationship to others, and said that
such freedom, appropriately expressed, often "avoids an excessive identity with the
culture of one's time." The problem for many individuals today, she said, is that in
their slothfulness individuals decide they will not stand apart from the exigencies of
their time. "In searching for a new self, they end up denying the self they've
got," she said.
Examples are found in biological obsessions, she said. "We are preoccupied with
overcoming ailments with will and skill. We search for cures for the human condition. Old
age becomes anomalous. We think about the selective destruction of what is abnormal. In
human engineering projects we wonder about choosing our descendants, selecting the lives
to come. We think of life as being marred by excessive pain and disease without being
concerned about who defines what excessive is
"
Other signs of the times, she said at one point, are in the political economy. "We
are possessed by what we possess, and everything seems to be for sale," she noted.
"We should discover ways to tame the market basis for our society."
These tendencies are a denial of humanity and its limits and a "repudiation of
finitude. Pride and sloth shake hands with each other and we tell ourselves that the more
control we have the better."
In such an instance, a scientist bent on cloning a human being argues that if a human
can be cloned than it must be done, and insists that God wants us to "live forever
like God
This is a form of idolatry. We are co-creators -- participants in creation,
not dominators of creation," Elshtain said.
In such a climate, individuals should trust the "wisdom of their repugnance. Pay
close attention to something you find repugnant and bring the matter to the front of your
critical consciousness. Repugnance is the kind of emotion that speaks up to our
humanity."
At one point, Elshtain responded to an audience question about a recent appearance on
the ABC-TV program, "Nightline," during which she appeared with President
Clinton's pastor. Asked to define her position on the program, Elshtain said she believes
that beyond the legal questions involving politicians, she feels an issue in society today
is "how we assess our public figures today. I think people have a right to expect
certain minimal standards of decency when issues threaten to undermine a public persona
or office. It's appropriate to be troubled about such matters and to talk about
them." But she said there is an increasing tendency today for such public discussions
to be limited to the legal arena.
The Hein-Fry Lecture Series identifies lively, pressing issues and offers lectures to
stimulate inquiry. The goals are to foster original scholarship, encourage dialogue and
give Evangelical Lutheran Church in America seminary faculties, students and others access
to leading theologians. |